Mayflies on BBC One review: Martin Compston brings the festive tears

A heartfelt and personable show delivered with a deeply sensitive sincerity
Tony Curran and Martin Compston picture as they star in Mayflies
Jamie Simpson/BBC/© Synchronicity Films/PA
Martin Robinson27 December 2022

Festive cheer is overrated, what about a good festive cry? Well, for those of us too repressed to let emotion out to family members, thankfully we have TV to help us at least let some out in their general vicinity.

And so to Mayflies, a BBC two-part series about how brief and precious life is. Adapted by Andrea Gibb, whose own partner died from cancer in 2018, this is a heartfelt and personable show delivered with a deeply sensitive sincerity. Basically, it’s ugly sob time, folks.

This heartfelt drama is an adaptation of a novel by Andrew O’Hagan and stars Martin Compston as novelist Jimmy, who goes back home to Scotland to visit his old friend Tully (Tony Curran), a rebellious musician.

Tully tells him he has terminal cancer and wants Jimmy to help him go to an assisted dying clinic in Switzerland – oh, and not tell the plan to his wife-to-be Anna (Ashley Jensen). The show goes to great lengths to explain why he doesn’t want her to know, without ever truly being convincing, which is somewhat unfortunate as it is the main engine of the plot.

408248,Mayflies
BBC/© Synchronicity Films

Still, in a drama such as this, it’s more about watching great actors being great, and for sure, Compston and Curran (real-life old friends since they were in the 2006 film Red Road together) make a powerful and warm pairing as they organise the wedding, a farewell gig, and wrestle with mortality.

It sounds impossibly grim but it actually isn’t, helped by extended flashback scenes of the young Jimmy (Rian Gordon) and Tully (an excellent Tom Glynn-Carney) back in the day when they were post-punk fans. This allows for a rollicking soundtrack of The Fall and Joy Division, and also makes an effective point about not just how quickly time goes by but how certain memories stay with you throughout your life, and how certain people are your life.

The scenes of the young days are notable for how soft-hearted the group of boys are: there’s piss-taking but no malice, and a lot of physical affection, which is a unique and refreshing take on male friendship groups which feels a little closer to the truth than most ‘lads, lads, lads’ depictions of young men. Such visible love between men is at the core of the scenes between Compston and Curran in a manner that feels unique too. And will eventually leave you crying out your internal organs.

Mayflies is not without flaws. Aside from that plot engine gripe, the supremely talented Tracy Ifeachor is a little under-used as Compston’s wife, Iona, and the script feels a little bit safe with regards to Tully’s one-liners: few deliver on being as outrageous or funny as his character is set up to be.

Nevertheless, this big hearted drama manages to stay away from sentimentality while turning you to mush. It may even convince you to make some emotional connections with your family, before you switch over to Gogglebox.

Mayflies will be on BBC iPlayer from December 27 and will air on BBC One on December 28

Create a FREE account to continue reading

eros

Registration is a free and easy way to support our journalism.

Join our community where you can: comment on stories; sign up to newsletters; enter competitions and access content on our app.

Your email address

Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number

You must be at least 18 years old to create an account

* Required fields

Already have an account? SIGN IN

By clicking Create Account you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use , Cookie policy and Privacy policy .

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in